Trinidad & Tobago against Trinidad & Tobago. The almanac states its case, the crowd votes, you decide.
Trinidad & Tobago · 1998–2006 · CM
The 1999 Trinidad and Tobago Pro League season brought him 45 goals and the Golden Boot, and the Caribbean named him its Footballer of the Year. Trinidad and Tobago Footballer of the Year in 1998, 1999 and 2001, a place in the 2000 Gold Cup All-Star team, 28 goals in 73 caps, the 2006 Pro League title with Joe Public, and two Caribbean club championships. Career record: club career at East Fife, Guangzhou, United Petrotrin.
Trinidad & Tobago · 2004–06 · CB
Andrews tore a cruciate ligament in his first season at Rangers, turned down the operation, missed one League Cup tie and was back the next week, and Ibrox took to playing "I'm a Believer" whenever he won man of the match. Scottish Premier League and League Cup double in 2005, the League Cup with Livingston in 2004, 101 caps for Trinidad and Tobago, and a 2006 World Cup the knee finally cost him. Career record: club career at Raith Rovers, Livingston, Rangers.
The almanac puts Marvin Andrews ahead by 1 rating point, 78 against 77.
Fans have not settled this one yet. Cast the first vote in the duels.