33·Legends

Marvin Andrews vs Shaka Hislop

Trinidad & Tobago against Trinidad & Tobago. The almanac states its case, the crowd votes, you decide.

MA

Marvin Andrews

Trinidad & Tobago · 2004–06 · CB

Almanac rating
78
Rank in Trinidad & Tobago
#9 of 33
Clubs
Raith Rovers, Livingston, Rangers

Andrews tore a cruciate ligament in his first season at Rangers, turned down the operation, missed one League Cup tie and was back the next week, and Ibrox took to playing "I'm a Believer" whenever he won man of the match. Scottish Premier League and League Cup double in 2005, the League Cup with Livingston in 2004, 101 caps for Trinidad and Tobago, and a 2006 World Cup the knee finally cost him. Career record: club career at Raith Rovers, Livingston, Rangers.

vs
SH

Shaka Hislop

Trinidad & Tobago · 1998–2006 · GK

Almanac rating
82
Rank in Trinidad & Tobago
#3 of 33
Clubs
Reading, West Ham United, Portsmouth

Dortmund, 10 June 2006: Hislop, 37, kept Zlatan Ibrahimović and Henrik Larsson out for 45 minutes with ten men, and Trinidad and Tobago drew their first World Cup match 0-0 in front of 62,959. First Division title with Portsmouth in 2003, Premier League runner-up twice with Newcastle, FA Cup finals in 1998 and 2006, 26 caps, and the first of the 2006 squad into his country's Sporting Hall of Fame. Career record: club career at Reading, West Ham United, Portsmouth.

The verdict

The almanac puts Shaka Hislop ahead by 4 rating points, 82 against 78.

Fans have not settled this one yet. Cast the first vote in the duels.

More arguments