On 28 June 1991 at the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum, in the opening match of the first Gold Cup, Bennett stepped up in the 28th minute and scored the tournament's first ever goal, a penalty in a 4-2 win over Canada. He took the 1995 Clausura in Argentina with San Lorenzo, played three Gold Cups for Honduras, scored 19 goals in 36 caps, and hit 44 in 111 games for Argentinos Juniors. Career record: 36 caps and 19 goals for Honduras; club career at C.F. Cobras de Querétaro, San Lorenzo de Almagro, Club Deportivo Victoria.
| 1988–1990 | C.D. Curacao |
| 1991–1993 | C.F. Cobras de Querétaro |
| 1991–1992 | C.D. Olimpia |
| 1993–1995 | San Lorenzo de Almagro |
| 1995–1999 | Argentinos Juniors |
| 2000–2000 | Cobreloa |
| 2000–2000 | Argentinos Juniors |
| 2001–2001 | Chacarita Juniors |
| 2001–2002 | Quilmes Atlético Club |
| 2001–2001 | Cobreloa |
| 2002–2002 | C.D. Olimpia |
| 2003–2004 | Club Deportivo Victoria |
| Honduras | 36 caps, 19 goals |
Honduras legends whose careers overlapped Bennett's
One rank above: Boniek García at #11.
One rank below: Gilberto Yearwood at #13.
Honduras's editorial top five: David Suazo · Amado Guevara · Wilson Palacios · Carlos Pavón · Maynor Figueroa.