Paul McGrath vs Tony Dunne
Both Ireland. The almanac states its case, the crowd votes, you decide.
Paul McGrath
Ireland · 1985–1997 · CB
- Rank in Ireland
- #4 of 33
- Caps · Republic of Ireland
- 83 · 8 goals
- Clubs
- St Patrick's Athletic, Manchester United, Aston Villa
"The Black Pearl" was a majestic defender for Aston Villa and Ireland, showcasing elegance and power that belied his injury struggles. Career record: 83 caps and 8 goals for Republic of Ireland; club career at St Patrick's Athletic, Manchester United, Aston Villa.
Tony Dunne
Ireland · 1962–1975 · LB
- Rank in Ireland
- #7 of 33
- Caps · Republic of Ireland
- 33 · 0 goals
- Clubs
- Shelbourne, Manchester United, Bolton Wanderers
Only Bobby Charlton and Bill Foulkes had played more games for Manchester United when he left in 1973, and on the night Benfica were beaten 4-1 at Wembley in 1968 he was there at left-back, quick, quiet, immaculate. Career record: 33 caps and 0 goals for Republic of Ireland; club career at Shelbourne, Manchester United, Bolton Wanderers.
The careers, side by side
Paul McGrath is editorial rank 4 and Tony Dunne rank 7 in Ireland's collection. Read the careers and make your own choice.
Fans have not settled this one yet. Cast the first vote in the duels.