Johnny Carey vs Paul McGrath
Both Ireland. The almanac states its case, the crowd votes, you decide.
Johnny Carey
Ireland · 1937–1953 · RB
- Rank in Ireland
- #3 of 33
- Caps · Republic of Ireland
- 29 · 3 goals
- Clubs
- Manchester United, Shamrock Rovers, Everton
The First Division title of 1952 followed, along with the 1949 Footballer of the Year award and the honour of captaining the Rest of Europe XI at Hampden in 1947. Career record: 29 caps and 3 goals for Republic of Ireland; club career at Manchester United, Shamrock Rovers, Everton.
Paul McGrath
Ireland · 1985–1997 · CB
- Rank in Ireland
- #4 of 33
- Caps · Republic of Ireland
- 83 · 8 goals
- Clubs
- St Patrick's Athletic, Manchester United, Aston Villa
"The Black Pearl" was a majestic defender for Aston Villa and Ireland, showcasing elegance and power that belied his injury struggles. Career record: 83 caps and 8 goals for Republic of Ireland; club career at St Patrick's Athletic, Manchester United, Aston Villa.
The careers, side by side
Johnny Carey is editorial rank 3 and Paul McGrath rank 4 in Ireland's collection. Read the careers and make your own choice.
Fans have not settled this one yet. Cast the first vote in the duels.