33·Legends

Gary Speed vs John Charles

Wales against Wales. The almanac states its case, the crowd votes, you decide.

Gary Speed

Gary Speed

Wales · CDM

Almanac rating
87
Rank in Wales
#8 of 33
Caps
85 · 7 goals
Clubs
Leeds United, Newcastle United, Bolton Wanderers
Honours
Hall of Fame 2010

The iconic captain who led Wales with distinction for years, Speed was a tirelessly energetic midfielder for Leeds, Newcastle, Everton, and Bolton. Career record: 85 caps and 7 goals for Wales; club career at Leeds United, Newcastle United, Bolton Wanderers; honours include Hall of Fame 2010.

vs
John Charles

John Charles

Wales · CB

Almanac rating
91
Rank in Wales
#2 of 33
Caps
38 · 15 goals
Clubs
Leeds United, Hereford United, Merthyr Tydfil
Honours
Hall of Fame

Blessed with immense versatility, the "Gentle Giant" was a world-class inside-forward for Juventus, but equally dominant as a centre-back for Wales and Leeds. Career record: 38 caps and 15 goals for Wales; club career at Leeds United, Hereford United, Merthyr Tydfil; honours include Hall of Fame.

The verdict

The almanac puts John Charles ahead by 4 rating points, 91 against 87.

Fans have not settled this one yet. Cast the first vote in the duels.

More arguments